| When I look into my heart I feel
 | 
| All of the hurt that was there
 | 
| Then I look into your eyes and see
 | 
| All of the joys that we’ve both shared
 | 
| I don’t wanna wish for love too hard
 | 
| But now all my dreams are of you
 | 
| And if dreams come true
 | 
| Then you’ll be my first time love
 | 
| There were moments before when I thought it was love
 | 
| But I know that it wasn’t nearly enough
 | 
| It’s so hard to remember my sad yesterdays
 | 
| And from now to December it’s Christmas always
 | 
| You know that it’s true
 | 
| Yes, you are my first time love
 | 
| Well, there may have been a few before
 | 
| But you are my first time love
 | 
| And nobody else could want you more than I do
 | 
| 'Cause it’s you that I love
 | 
| Yes, it’s you that I love and never more again
 | 
| Could there be a better friend
 | 
| Oh, I had my wish, now my wish has come true
 | 
| I needed some love and then there was you
 | 
| Couldn’t ask for more
 | 
| 'Cause you are my first time love
 | 
| It’s so hard to remember my sad yesterdays
 | 
| And from now to December it’s Christmas always
 | 
| You know that it’s true
 | 
| Yes, you are my first time love
 | 
| Well, there may have been a few before
 | 
| But you are my first time love
 | 
| And nobody else could want you more than I do
 | 
| 'Cause it’s you that I love
 | 
| Yes, it’s you that I love and never more again
 | 
| Could there be a better friend
 | 
| Oh, I had my wish, now my wish has come true
 | 
| I needed some love and then there was you
 | 
| Couldn’t ask for more
 | 
| 'Cause you are my first time love
 | 
| You are my first time love
 | 
| You are my first time love, love |