| It must have been the mistletoe | 
| The lazy fire | 
| The fallin' snow | 
| The magic in the frosty air | 
| That feeling everywhere | 
| It must have been the pretty lights | 
| That glistened in the Silent Night | 
| Or maybe just the stars so bright that shined above you | 
| Our first (first) Christmas more then we’d been dreaming of | 
| Old Saint (Old Saint) Nicolas had his fingers crossed that we would fall in love | 
| It could have been the holiday | 
| The midnight ride upon a sleigh | 
| The country side all dressed in white | 
| That crazy snowball fight | 
| It could have been the steeple bell | 
| That wrapped us up within it’s spell | 
| It only took one kiss to know | 
| It must have been the mistletoe | 
| Our first (first) Christmas more then we’d been dreaming of | 
| Old Saint (Old Saint) Nicolas must have known that kiss would leave to all of | 
| this | 
| It must have been the mistletoe | 
| The lazy fire | 
| The fallin' snow | 
| The magic in the frosty air | 
| That made me love you | 
| On Christmas eve a wish came true | 
| The night I fell in love with you | 
| It only took one kiss to know | 
| It must have been (the mistletoe) | 
| It must have been the mistletoe (mistletoe) | 
| The lazy fire, the fallin' snow (fallin' snow) | 
| The magic in the frosty air | 
| That feeling everywhere | 
| It must have been the mistletoe (mistletoe) | 
| The lazy fire, the fallin' snow (fallin' snow) | 
| The magic in the frosty air | 
| That made me love you | 
| It must have been the mistletoe (mistletoe) | 
| The lazy fire, the fallin' snow (fallin' snow) | 
| The magic in the frosty air | 
| That feeling everywhere |